13 local Birmingham Etsy shops offering unique holiday stocking stuffers

Birmingham, Etsy, gifts, stocking stuffers, presents, holidays, Christmas
Birmingham, Etsy, gifts, stocking stuffers, presents, holidays, Christmas
Have you filled those stockings yet? Photo via Oliver and Olivia App on Etsy

Looking for the best stocking stuffers for every member of your family? Consider these finds from local Etsy shops in Birmingham.

Lily Magnolia Boutique

Birmingham, Etsy, lilymagnoliaboutique, coasters, Alabama, gifts, stocking stuffers, cork
Photo via Lily Magnolia Boutique on Etsy

If there’s one thing you can never have too many of, it’s coasters. And it’s hard to resist this Alabama-inspired set by Lily Magnolia Boutique.

Made with thick, high-quality cork, each set of coasters are hand cut and painted with the design of your choice.


Dimensions are 4×4″ squares, 1/4″ thick.

Price: $10

Buy it here.


Neat Knit Gifts

Birmingham, Etsy, NeatKnitGifts, crochet, toys, stocking stuffers, gifts
Photo via Neat Knit Gifts on Etsy

Do you know a little one celebrating their very first Christmas? These amigurumi animals from local Birmingham Etsy shop Neat Knit Gifts make the sweetest gift.

Each animal is made to order and crocheted with soft 100% acrylic yarn. Sizes range from six inches and up.

Price: $17+


Buy it here.

Kelita Farm Soap

Birmingham, Etsy, KelitaFarmSoap, soap, gifts
Photo via Kelita Farm Soap on Etsy

One of the all-time simplest gifts to buy and give is decorative soaps. They smell great, look pretty and are always well-received. So head over to Kelita Farm Soap on Etsy for some amazing finds. 

Birmingham, Etsy, KelitaFarmSoap, soap, gifts
Photo via Kelita Farm Soap on Etsy

The peppermint scented gift soap is one choice that’s perfect for the holiday season. Along with a delicious candy cane-like aroma, it also comes with:


  • Shea butter loofah massage soap bar
  • Shea butter lotion
  • Dead Sea soaking bath salts

Price: $19

Buy it here.

Be More Random

Birmingham, Etsy, BeMoreRandom, mugs, ceramics
Ceramic Mug. Photo via Be More Random on Etsy

People tend to fall into two categories—easy to shop for and downright impossible to shop for.


If you’re searching for a gift for someone on the difficult list, how about something easy like this ceramic mug from local Etsy shop Be More Random.

Mugs are always a worthwhile gift because they have many purposes. Plus, if your giftee lives in Birmingham, a Magic City-inspired mug is even more meaningful.

Price: $8


Buy it here.

Berry Lafontaine

Birmingham, Etsy, BerryLafontaine, baby Yoda, Yoda, Star Wars, stocking stuffers, gifts, crochet
Baby Yoda is too cute for words. Berry Lafontaine

It’s hard not to like Yoda. But baby Yoda takes the love to a whole new level!

Handmade from soft, velvet-like polyester yarn, this baby Yoda stands just over three inches tall.


This may look like a child’s toy, but I guarantee even the oldest Star Wars fans will get a kick out of this gift.

Price: $25

Buy it here.


My Shadywood Workshop

Birmingham, Etsy, MyShadywoodWorkShop, mug cozies, gifts, stocking stuffers
Fleece mug cozies for warm winter drinks. Photo via My Shadywood WorkShop on Etsy

Winter temps mean warm drinks. From coffee to hot cocoa, these fleece mug cozies are both sweet and stylish and are a stocking stuffer that all can enjoy. Set includes six cozies.

Price: $20

Buy it here.


Stone Cold Whiskey

Birmingham, Etsy, StoneColdWhiskey, whiskey, whiskey cubes, gifts
Keep your cocktails chill with whiskey rocks. Photo via Stone Cold Whiskey on Etsy

Give the gift of cold drinks and warm memories with Stone Cold Whiskey Rocks.

Simply place the stones in the bag provided and store them in your freezer to keep them nice and cold.

Ready for a cocktail? Place two-three stones into your glass, let sit for three-five minutes and enjoy chilled liquor without watering it down with melted ice cubes.


What’s especially cool is that the rocks are made of white marble by fourth generation stone craftsmen.

Each package includes nine cubes.

Price: $19.99


Buy it here.

Fulton Craft

Birmingham, Etsy, FultonCraft, personalized gifts, hammers, tools
A personalized hammer is practical and special. Photo via Fulton Craft on Etsy

There’s something to be said for giving useful presents. And all can find good use for this hammer from Fulton Craft. The best part—you can personalize it for that special touch.

Price: $29.50+


Buy it here.

Sassy Anns Shop

Birmingham, Etsy, SassyAnnsShop, necklaces, jewelry, gifts
Tassel necklace. Photo via Sassy Anns Shop on Etsy

Want to jazz up that stocking? As the saying goes, the best gifts come in small packages. So consider some jewelry.

Sassy Anns Shop offers lots of nice choices, including these tassel necklaces that are perfect for any outfit.


Birmingham, Etsy, SassyAnnsShop, jewelry, tassel necklace
Tassel necklace. Photo via Sassy Anns Shop on Etsy

Price: $25.75

Buy it here.

Southern Farmhouse

Birmingham, Etsy, SouthernFarmhouse, The Wishful Ornament, ornaments, stocking stuffers, gifts
The Wishful Ornament. Photo via Southern Farmhouse on Etsy

Whether it’s used this holiday season or next, ornaments make a great stocking stuffers that can be used for years to come. Check out The Wishful Ornaments from Southern Farmhouse on Etsy.


Made with wood, each initial ornaments is four inches tall and adorned with a burlap bow.

Birmingham, Etsy, SouthernFarmhouse, The Wishful Ornament, ornaments, stocking stuffers, gifts
The Wishful Ornament. Photo via Southern Farmhouse on Etsy

The more you buy, the more you’ll save, so go ahead and purchase an ornament for your whole crew. Here’s a look at pricing:

  • 1 ornament for $8.50 each
  • 5 ornaments for $7.50 each
  • 10 ornaments for $6.75 each
  • 15 ornaments for $6.50 each
  • 20 ornaments for $5.75 each

Buy it here.


Elidia the Label

Birmingham, Etsy, ElidiatheLabel, gifts, leather goods, card holder, credit card holder, business card holder, gifts, stocking stuffers
Handmade leather business card/credit card holder. Photo via Elidia the Label on Etsy

For the one on your shopping list that loves to pass out or collect business cards, this handmade leather card holder is the perfect find.

Made by Elidia the Label, each business card holder is made from sturdy leather and can hold four or more cards. Dimensions are 4″ h x 2.5″ w.

Price: $21.60


Buy it here.

Night Owl Paper Goods

Birmingham, Etsy, NightOwlPaperGoods, Cyber Monday, stocking stuffers, calendars, gifts
Fun food desk calendar. Photo via Night Owl Paper Goods on Etsy

Night Owl Paper Goods is one of my favorite local Etsy shops. In fact, I’ve mentioned them in previous Etsy guides. If you enjoy fun, silly items, then you’ll become an instant fan, too!

For a worthwhile stocking stuffer, check out their Fun Food Desk Calendar. It features:


  • 12 foodie cuties – one for each month of the year.
  • Eco-friendly, FSC-certified cover stock made with zero-emission, wind-generated power.
  • A clear, reusable jewel case/stand.

Dimensions are 4.5″ x 5.5″.

Can you think of a better way to help someone bring in the 2020 year?

Price: $12.75


Buy it here.

Austin Leathercraft

Birmingham, Etsy, AustinLeathercraft, guitar strap, guitars, instruments, music, leather goods, stocking stuffers, gifts
Buffalo leather guitar strap. Photo via Austin Leathercraft on Etsy

Buying for a musician this holiday season? A guitarist will love this guitar strap from Austin Leathercraft. Hand made from high-quality buffalo leather, it is sure to to make musician and listeners swoon.

Price: $49


Buy it here.

Which Birmingham Etsy shop offers your favorite stocking stuffers? Let us know what other shops are out there!