Birmingham OKs razing 3 historic Highland Ave. apartment buildings. See what’s next

Reading time: 3 minutes

IMG 4746 scaled e1795030887775 Birmingham OKs razing 3 historic Highland Ave. apartment buildings. See what's next
The Phares Apartments on Highland Avenue. (Pat Byington / Bham Now)

In a unanimous vote, the Birmingham Design Review Committee approved a motion to demolish three historic apartment buildings on and near Highland Avenue.

The apartments, which were built in the 1920s, are located across from the former Freddy’s Wine Bar space near Caldwell Park at:

The Highland Park Neighborhood Association Local Historic Advisory Committee opposed the demolition.

Why the buildings are coming down

The measure to demolish the buildings was supported by a study conducted by Structural Design Group,  a Hoover-based structural engineering firm.

Stewart Lee, the founder of Structural Design Group, concluded:

“..building has exceeded its useful life and is not capable of being repaired by any means that preserve it as the structure it is.”

Lee also reported that the buildings were not economically viable to repair or renovate.

Brian Wolfe, Vice Chair of the Design Review Committee expressed frustration at the meeting about the demise of the buildings.

“It breaks my heart to see things get to this level of condition, and that’s a whole other discussion about things in our city. If they were only taken care of over time, we could be reusing those assets. Unfortunately, that’s not always the case.”

What’s planned next

David Silverstein, Jr. with the Five Stone Group revealed the conceptual plan to replace the buildings, which includes 90 apartments in total and possible retail if zoning is approved by the city.

Below are the renderings.

261118 DRC Presentation FINAL Page 179 Image 0001 Birmingham OKs razing 3 historic Highland Ave. apartment buildings. See what's next
Conceptual rendering of the former Caldwell Parc and Phares Apartment site at on Highland Avenue. (Birmingham Design Review)
261118 DRC Presentation FINAL Page 182 Image 0001 Birmingham OKs razing 3 historic Highland Ave. apartment buildings. See what's next
Conceptual design plan rendering of the former Baycourt Apartments site at 1054 24th St. South. (Birmingham Design Review)

In an interview with Bham Now after the vote, Silverstein promised to continue to work with the neighborhood on the designs for the new development plan which will eventually need to be approved by the Design Review Committee.

“We’re very pleased with the outcome of the decision. I think the committee ultimately looked at the facts and the supporting evidence and made the right conclusion.

We’re going to continue to work with the local committees in the neighborhood to make sure that what ultimately gets replaced will be compatible with the district, and look forward to continuing those discussions.”

Pat Byington
Pat Byington

Longtime conservationist. Former Executive Director at the Alabama Environmental Council and Wild South. Publisher of the Bama Environmental News for more than 18 years. Career highlights include playing an active role in the creation of Alabama's Forever Wild program, Little River Canyon National Preserve, Dugger Mountain Wilderness, preservation of special places throughout the East through the Wilderness Society and the strengthening (making more stringent) the state of Alabama's cancer risk and mercury standards.

Articles: 3401