Birmingham-area spots named among best barbecue chicken in the US

Reading time: 3 minutes

Rustys BBQ 2 edited scaled Birmingham-area spots named among best barbecue chicken in the US
While you’re trying out the chicken at Rusty’s, go ahead and try out some of the classic Southern sides on the menu. (Bham Now)

National food publication The Takeout recently released its list of the 14 best barbecue restaurant chickens in the United States, and the Birmingham metro area claimed two spots.

While pork and brisket usually dominate local smokehouse conversations, these two local joints are getting national recognition for excellence in the art of smoked poultry.

Here is a look at the Birmingham-area restaurants that made the cut, along with another legendary Alabama spot that secured a position on the national list.

Miss Myra’s Pit Bar-B-Q serves award-winning flavor in Cahaba Heights

Miss Myra's Pit Bar-B-Q
If you haven’t tried Miss Myra’s pecan pie what are you waiting for? (Sharron Swain / Bham Now)

Family-run since 1984, Miss Myra’s Pit Bar-B-Q has long been a staple of the Birmingham culinary scene. The Cahaba Heights institution utilizes a custom-built brick pit and hickory wood to slow-smoke its meats.

The Takeout highlighted Miss Myra’s half-chickens, noting the perfect balance of crisp skin and juicy meat. The publication also praised the signature white barbecue sauce, which delivers a distinct tang without overpowering the deep hickory smoke flavor.

The spot has earned fans far beyond Alabama, including four-time James Beard Award winner Andrew Zimmern, who previously named it some of the best barbecue chicken he has ever eaten.

Rusty’s Bar-B-Q brings backyard traditions to Leeds

Rustys BBQ Birmingham-area spots named among best barbecue chicken in the US
Rusty’s has some top-tier barbecue chicken, if we do say so ourselves. (Rusty’s Bar-B-Q)

Located just outside Birmingham in Leeds, Rusty’s Bar-B-Q earned high marks for its tender, wood-smoked chicken. Owner Rusty Tucker combines formal culinary training with the traditional, backyard smoking techniques passed down from his father, The Takeout wrote.

According to the national ranking, the bone-in smoked chicken stands out for its deep smoke penetration and consistent moisture. Local patrons frequently cite it on online forums as a top contender for the best smoked chicken in the state.

Legendary North Alabama icon completes the state sweep

The Birmingham area was not the only region represented on the national roundup. The Takeout also recognized an iconic brand further north that helped shape the identity of Alabama barbecue.

Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q in Decatur

Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Que
(Visit North Alabama)

No list of elite smoked chicken would be complete without the birthplace of Alabama white sauce.

Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q in Decatur has been a Southern-food-lover’s destination for more than a century. The restaurant is famous for its method of submerging whole hickory-smoked chickens into a vat of mayonnaise-and-vinegar-based white sauce immediately after pulling them from the pit, ensuring the meat remains exceptionally moist.

Mary Helene Hall
Mary Helene Hall

Breaking Content Producer. Casual birder + enjoyer of the Alabama outdoors. Frequent coffee shop patron. Ravenous reader. Previously @ AL.com, Georgia Trust for Local News, Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Get in touch at maryhelene@bhamnow.com.

Articles: 441