Reviewed by: Cindy Hatcher
See inside 2 luxury listings in one of Mountain Brook’s hidden neighborhoods
Reading time: 4 minutes
Sponsored
Abingdon is one of Mountain Brook’s quieter, tucked-away neighborhoods: an enclave of custom homes between Altadena, Vestavia Hills and Cahaba Heights. With long winding roads, wooded lots and estate-sized properties, it feels private and removed—yet it’s just minutes from some of Birmingham’s busiest corridors.
Homes here don’t come up often. And when they do, they tend to make a statement.
Right now, two multi-million dollar properties on Abingdon Trail are showcasing the scale, craftsmanship and lifestyle that define this pocket of Mountain Brook. Read on for an inside tour with two local agents.
The best of both worlds
What makes Abingdon especially appealing is its balance of privacy and proximity. Though tucked away, the neighborhood sits at the crossroads of some of the metro’s most established communities:
- Less than 5 minutes to Highway 280
- Less than 10 minutes to Mountain Brook Village + The Summit
- Roughly 10 minutes to downtown Birmingham
For the modern enthusiast
4217 Abingdon Trail (Daniel McAllister)
Modern homes are rare in Mountain Brook, and this one is as modern as they come.
Designed and built by architect Keith Russell in the 1980s, this home stands out for its clean lines, open layout and wall-to-wall glass that seamlessly blends indoors and outdoors.
Set on approximately 2 private acres, the five-bedroom, seven-bath (and two half-bath) home feels more like a vacation retreat than a traditional Southern estate.
The primary suite includes dramatic ceilings, a fireplace, two walk-in closets and a spa-like bath with floor-to-ceiling windows and a soaking tub. Downstairs, the basement opens to a true backyard oasis—complete with a gunite pool, pool bath, bar area and plenty of space to soak up the sun.
The recent renovation leans fully into its modern identity:
- New European kitchen featuring Arrital Italian cabinetry + MIELE German appliances
- Large Italian marble countertop designed for gathering
- Sub-Zero refrigerator, Bosch dishwasher, wine cooler + warming drawer
“Hands down, the new kitchen and luxurious master bath compliment the original modern design for the home. The seller cleverly chose the most important rooms to renovate. I like to say this home has two of everything a buyer would need!”
Buffy Bromberg Allen, Agent, Ray & Poynor
For the cozy-loving host with the most
4249 Abingdon Trail (Daniel McAllister)
Down the street, 4249 Abingdon Trail offers another impressive approach to luxury living.
From the grand foyer with detailed wall molding to the wood-paneled study and marble-clad primary bath, craftsmanship defines this home. Set on more than 2 acres in the Mountain Brook school district, the estate blends everyday functionality with high-end amenities.
“This thoughtfully designed home truly lives well. Every space has been intentionally planned to support both family life and effortless entertaining.”
Jane Huston Crommelin, Agent, Ray & Poynor
Standout features include:
- An expansive pool + patio area
- A double-sided fireplace connecting the sitting room + den
- A luxurious primary suite with fireplace, sitting area + private laundry
Upstairs, four additional bedrooms, a cozy den and a playroom offer plenty of space for family and guests. The finished basement elevates the lifestyle even further with a 14-seat theater room, fitness area, game room, in-law suite and full wet bar.
Outside, French doors lead to a bluestone patio and resort-style pool complete with wall jets, built-in firepit and custom gazebo, creating an all-inclusive retreat without ever leaving home.
SOLD: For the extravagant entertainer
4229 Abingdon Trail (Brendon Pinola)
Last but not least, we had to give an honorable mention to another Abingdon house that recently sold for $3.2M.
This grand, ornate Mountain Brook home was such a hot commodity that it flew off the market—listed, pending and closed all within a week.
Inside, 4229 Abingdon Trail offers abundant space and thoughtful design that takes you back to the days before minimalism became trendy: monochromatic rooms, wallpaper everywhere and a bathroom straight out of a Venetian spa.
Residences in Abingdon seldom become available, making the debut of three offerings at once exceptionally rare. It also offers a glimpse inside some of the neighborhood’s most distinctive and beautifully appointed homes, tucked quietly away from view.
Buying, selling or seeking expert advice? Ray & Poynor can help.
Sponsored by:
